Showing posts with label Jobs created. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jobs created. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

More Garbage-In-Garbage-Out from CBO

You don't need to watch old Gunsmoke episodes if you want to travel into the past. Just read the latest Congressional Budget Office "research" claiming that Obama's so-called stimulus "increased the number of full-time-equivalent jobs by 1.8 million to 4.1 million." CBO's analysis is a throwback to the widely discredited Keynesian theory that assumes you can enrich yourself by switching money from your left pocket to right pocket. For all intents and purposes, CBO wants us to believe their Keynesian model and ignore real world data. This is akin to the famous line attributed to Willie Nelson, who was caught with another woman by his wife and supposedly said, "Are you going to believe me or your lying eyes?"

Using its own Keynesian model, the White House last year said that wasting $800 billion was necessary to keep the unemployment rate from rising above 8 percent. Yet the joblessness rate quickly jumped to 10 percent and remains stubbornly high. We've already beaten this dead horse (here, here, here, here, and here) in part because the White House has embarrassed itself even further with silly attempts to find some way of turning a sow's ear into a silk purse. This is why Obama Administration estimates have evolved from "jobs created" to "jobs saved" to "jobs financed."

The CBO's most recent "calculations" are just another version of the same economic alchemy. But don't believe me. Buried at the end of the report is this passage, where CBO basically admits that its new "research" simply plugged new spending numbers into its Keynesian formula. This sounds absurd, and it is, but don't forget that these are the same geniuses that predicted that a giant new healthcare entitlement would reduce long-run budget deficits.

CBO’s current estimates of the impact of ARRA on output and employment differ slightly from those presented in its February 2010 report primarily because the agency has revised its estimates of ARRA’s impact on federal spending on the basis of new information. Outlays resulting from ARRA in the first quarter of calendar year 2010 were higher than the amount that CBO projected in February 2010 in preparing its estimate of the law’s likely impact on output and employment, primarily because a larger-than-expected amount of refundable tax credits was disbursed in the first quarter rather than later in the year. That change makes the estimated impact of ARRA on output and employment in the first quarter slightly higher than what CBO projected in February.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

So-Called Stimulus Spending Means Fewer Jobs, Part I

The Administration is arguing that last year's $800 billion spending bill has created jobs. But since the unemployment rate is higher and the total number of Americans with jobs has fallen, the White House can only make this claim by arguing that the unemployment rate would be even higher without all the new spending. This argument is seductive to those (such as journalists) who don't understand that government can't dump money into the economy without first taking money out of the economy. But there are more reasons why so-called stimulus spending is bad for the economy and job creation. Writing for Investor's Business Daily, Alan Reynolds of the Cato Institute points out that the recession lasted longer than average and that much of the spending was for programs that subsidize people for not working:

President Obama seized on the one-year anniversary of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) as an opportunity to take credit for the belated and tenuous economic recovery. But the economy always recovered from recessions, long before anyone imagined that government borrowing could "create jobs." And we didn't used to have to wait nearly two years for signs of recovery, as we did this time. A famous 1999 study by Christina Romer, who now heads the Council of Economic Advisers, found the average length of recessions from 1887 to 1929 was only 10.3 months, with the longest lasting 16 months. ...The bill was launched last year amid grandiose promises of "shovel ready" make-work projects. In reality, as the CBO explains, "five programs accounted for more than 80% of the outlays from ARRA in 2009: Medicaid, unemployment compensation, Social Security ... grants to state and local governments ... and student aid." In other words, what was labeled a "stimulus" bill was actually a stimulus to government transfer payments — cash and benefits that are primarily rewards for not working, or at least not working too hard.

Monday, January 25, 2010

Doubling Down on Big Government

This new video from the Center for Freedom and Prosperity explains how last year's so-called stimulus was a flop - and also reveals why politicians are pushing for another big-government spending bill.



Interestingly, since last year's stimulus was such a disaster, the redistributionists in Washington are calling their new proposal a "jobs bill." But as I say in the video, this is akin to putting perfume on a hog.